Carney and Poilievre Clash in High-Stakes French Debate Focused on Trump, Economy, and Leadership

Prime Minister Mark Carney faced off against his chief rival, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, for the first time in Wednesday night’s French-language leaders’ debate—an encounter that could prove pivotal in shaping the outcome of Canada’s April 28 federal election.

Held in Montreal, the debate marked a crucial moment in the campaign, especially with Quebec’s 78 seats often playing a decisive role in forming government. It was also the first televised confrontation between Carney and Poilievre since Carney was elected leader of the Liberal Party in March.

Carney, whose French fluency has drawn scrutiny, managed to exceed expectations during the event. According to pollster Jean-Marc Leger, Carney performed strongly and avoided any major missteps. The prime minister leaned heavily on his global experience as a former governor of both the Bank of Canada and the Bank of England, positioning himself as best equipped to confront U.S. President Donald Trump, who has not only imposed sweeping tariffs on Canadian goods but even floated the idea of annexing Canada.

“This election is about who has the strength to face Trump,” Carney said, rejecting comparisons to former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. “Mr. Poilievre is not Mr. Trudeau, and neither am I.”

- Advertisement -

Poilievre countered with sharp criticism, accusing Carney of representing continuity rather than change. “You are just like Justin Trudeau,” he said, claiming that Carney would continue the same policies that have worsened housing affordability and increased the cost of living. He also attacked Carney’s record in the U.K., alleging that housing prices soared under his leadership at the Bank of England.

While Carney defended his role as an economist and negotiator, Poilievre framed himself as the candidate for working Canadians, promising to reduce taxes and unleash Canada’s natural resource potential. He argued that the Liberals had undermined the economy by blocking energy projects and pursuing aggressive tax policies.

Despite the fiery exchanges, both leaders earned praise from political commentators for their performances. Conservative strategist Dimitri Soudas said both Carney and Poilievre delivered strong showings, though he noted Poilievre may have missed a key opportunity to win over undecided voters.

The debate was held two hours earlier than originally scheduled to avoid competing with a critical NHL playoff game featuring the Montreal Canadiens—highlighting the province’s cultural priorities.