As the U.S. Supreme Court deliberates on the constitutionality of a federal TikTok ban, Canadian users are left wondering if their government will follow suit. The potential ban, set to take effect on January 19 unless TikTok’s parent company ByteDance sells its U.S. assets, has reignited discussions on national security and data privacy in Canada.
The U.S. TikTok Ban: What’s Happening?
The TikTok ban, passed into law in April 2024, was included in an aid package supporting Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan. American lawmakers argue that ByteDance, TikTok’s China-based parent company, could be compelled to share user data with the Chinese government under China’s National Intelligence Law. TikTok denies these claims and has vowed to fight the ban in court, calling it an unconstitutional overreach.
If implemented, the ban would remove TikTok from app stores like Apple’s and Google’s, preventing new downloads in the U.S., while existing users could still access the app. Additionally, internet hosting services would be barred from supporting TikTok.
How Could This Affect Canadian Users?
In Canada, TikTok was banned from government-issued devices nearly two years ago, citing similar national security concerns. While the app remains accessible to the general public, a U.S. ban could influence Canadian policy. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has emphasized prioritizing the privacy and security of Canadians, while also acknowledging the innovative potential of platforms like TikTok.
A ban in the U.S. could set a precedent, potentially prompting Canada to reevaluate its stance. Vass Bednar, a digital policy expert, noted that Canada often aligns its actions with the U.S. in such matters, making a similar ban likely if TikTok remains a security concern.
The Broader Implications of a Ban
Experts caution that banning TikTok alone won’t resolve broader issues of data security. Social media platforms worldwide, including U.S.-based apps, collect vast amounts of user data with limited transparency. Philip Mai of Toronto Metropolitan University’s Social Media Lab argues that the focus should shift to strengthening cybersecurity and privacy policies rather than targeting individual platforms.
Even seemingly harmless apps, such as fitness trackers, have unintentionally exposed sensitive data. For example, Strava, a popular fitness app, inadvertently revealed the locations of U.S. military bases in Syria. This underscores the importance of scrutinizing how all apps handle user data, not just those tied to foreign entities.
Canadian Influencers and Economic Impact
A Canadian TikTok ban could disrupt the livelihoods of influencers who rely on the platform for their reach and income. While the federal government conducted a national security review of TikTok, Industry Minister François-Philippe Champagne previously downplayed the risks for everyday users.
Bednar also highlighted a contradiction in Canadian policy: despite banning TikTok from government devices, the government spent over a million dollars advertising on the platform between 2022 and 2023.
Data Security Beyond TikTok
Experts warn that a TikTok ban could create a false sense of security. Bednar explained that other platforms, including U.S.-based social media apps, often employ similarly aggressive data collection practices. Addressing these systemic issues requires comprehensive privacy reforms and transparent data policies, rather than focusing solely on individual companies.
As the U.S. moves closer to a TikTok ban, Canada faces critical decisions about balancing innovation, national security, and data protection. Whether or not Canada follows its neighbor’s lead, the conversation around TikTok highlights the need for stronger data privacy measures across all digital platforms.
Discover more from Weekly Voice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
