Toronto Police Inspector Joyce Schertzer has been demoted to the rank of staff sergeant for nine months following disciplinary action over her involvement in a collision investigation involving her nephew. The penalty was announced on Monday by retired OPP Superintendent Lisa Taylor during a disciplinary tribunal hearing.
Misconduct and Investigation Details
The incident occurred on May 1, 2022, when Schertzer’s nephew crashed his pickup truck into a city-owned utility pole on Lake Shore Boulevard. Tribunal documents revealed that Schertzer, while on duty at 11 Division, arranged for an officer from her division to respond to the crash, bypassing standard protocols. Schertzer also attended the scene in person, later claiming she mistakenly believed the collision occurred within 11 Division’s jurisdiction.
The officer investigating the collision allowed Schertzer’s nephew, a G2-licensed driver, to leave the scene within 10 minutes. This expedited process left no opportunity to assess whether alcohol could have been a contributing factor, though there was no evidence of impairment. Schertzer defended her actions, stating she observed no signs of alcohol use in her nephew.
Tribunal Findings and Rationale
The tribunal found Schertzer guilty of discreditable conduct and neglect of duty, emphasizing that her actions could be perceived as favoritism toward family members. Taylor noted that the public would expect high-ranking officers to uphold stricter standards of conduct, adding that Schertzer’s decision to turn off her body-worn camera for a private conversation with the investigating officer would likely “shock” the average citizen.
While the tribunal acknowledged Schertzer’s positive 30-year policing career and impressive letters of support from colleagues, it also criticized her for failing to recognize that her actions were inappropriate. Taylor concluded that the incident caused reputational harm to the Toronto Police Service.
Penalty and Future Reinstatement
Schertzer’s demotion is temporary, and she will return to her rank as inspector after the nine-month period. Despite the media scrutiny and misconduct allegations, Taylor commended Schertzer for her continued dedication to the police service. However, the tribunal stressed that the incident underscored the need for accountability, even among senior officers, to maintain public trust in law enforcement.
