As Alberta Premier Danielle Smith entertains the possibility of a separation referendum in 2026, constitutional experts and Indigenous leaders are pushing back hard, warning that the idea is not only unrealistic but legally and morally fraught. Even if a majority of Albertans voted “yes” in a hypothetical referendum, that alone would not trigger secession. It would instead mark the beginning of a long, complex legal and political showdown involving treaty rights, federal law, and international recognition.
Chief Troy Bossman Knowlton of the Piikani Nation, speaking on behalf of more than 20 Indigenous leaders at an emergency meeting, called the idea “insanity” and warned of significant resistance. Speaking to CTV News, he said First Nations could halt development and exploration on their lands if their treaty rights were ignored, asserting, “We are not going anywhere.”
That resistance carries legal weight. Every inch of Alberta is covered by treaty territory or national parks, meaning Indigenous consent would be crucial in any separation process. According to University of Calgary law professor Kathleen Mahoney, those treaties are binding legal agreements with the Crown, and Canada’s adoption of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) only strengthens those obligations. “It’s really not within the realm of possibility,” she said, adding that any renegotiation would require federal involvement and support from two-thirds of Canada’s provinces representing at least half the population.
Even if Alberta cleared those hurdles, it would face a daunting list of logistical negotiations. University of Alberta constitutional scholar Eric Adams noted that the process would resemble Quebec’s decades-long flirtation with independence — only with far more modern complications. Alberta would need to negotiate everything from trade, pensions, and policing to national debt, border controls, and even a currency. International recognition would be no small feat either, particularly given Canada’s alliances with most Western democracies.
“Where Alberta fits into North America — its relationship with Canada and the U.S. — all of that would need to be determined through years of painful political negotiations,” Adams said.
Premier Smith, meanwhile, has refused to speculate on the full feasibility of separation. “I don’t have answers to those questions,” she said, adding that until an official question and petition are brought forward, “it really is just hypothetical.”
For more political coverage, visit weeklyvoice.com and weeklyvoice.com/category/canada.
Discover more from Weekly Voice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
